Home / Contract Awards / Alan Chvotkin from the Professional Services Council Reviews Cases Involving Protests of Contract Awards

Alan Chvotkin from the Professional Services Council Reviews Cases Involving Protests of Contract Awards

Alan Chvotkin

In his debut column, Alan Chvotkin, executive vice president and counsel of the Professional Services Council, analyzes two recent cases involving the government contracting selection process.

In each case contractors protested what they considered were flawed methods in the government’s source selection and filed a protest. Chvotkin reviews the implications of these post-award protests.

One case involved a Veterans Administration Transformation Twenty-One Total Technology Next Generation (T4NG) contract worth between $700 million and $1 billion that Cognosante bid on. The Government Accountability Office announced a decision in February 2019 and recommended that the VA reevaluate all contract offers.

“The VA received seven bids and set a competitive range of six proposals. GAO disclosed that Cognosante was third lowest in price, was significantly higher than the price offered by the lowest-priced offeror but was significantly below the price of the apparent successful offeror,” Chvotkin wrote.

In another case Citizant, Inc, filed its post-award protest challenging the General Services Administration’s evaluation of proposals under the government-wide, multiple-award, ID/IQ Alliant 2 Small Business information technology contract. In March 2019 the U.S. Court of Federal Claims found that GSA made errors in their evaluation process and ordered GSA to reevaluate all the proposals it received.

“For the court to find these agency mistakes in GSA’s source selection evaluation is troubling for all the small business vendors who invested a lot of time and money in the preparation and submission of their offers,” Chvotkin wrote.

This is the first in an ongoing series of columns by Alan Chvotkin and colleagues at the Professional Services Council.

Check Also

Leidos Wins Navy Synthetic Signature Generation Trainer Contract

Leidos (NYSE: LDOS) has won a potential three-year, $63M contract to develop, engineer and integrate a training system based on synthetic signature generation technology for the U.S. Navy. The company will also help the service brancg test, implement and maintain the SSG trainer as part of the cost-plus-fixed-fee, indefinite-delivery/indefinite-quantity contract, the Department of Defense said Tuesday.

Bechtel Wins $383M Contract to Design, Build NASA’s Second Mobile Launcher

Bechtel has been awarded a 44-month, $383M contract to design, construct, test and commission a second mobile launcher at NASA's Kennedy Space Center. NASA said Wednesday it will use the ML2 to assemble, process and launch the Space Launch System rocket with the Orion spacecraft on missions moon and Mars. The platform will be built to support KSC's exploration ground systems.